At first I wasn't super enthused about it, but then we were driving around and I realized that we really have a ton of songs that are "ours." Music is really important to both of us (made obvious by the fact that we both have a million CDs in the car and each of us have our own CD holder attached to a visor) and while we have opposite tastes in music sometimes, we each like each others' favorites (well, for the most part. I think Calvin draws the line at some of my "girl" music and some of his hardcore rock is a little too, well, hardcore for me). I think it will be fun to have a booklet included with the CDs too describing why we chose each song, because so many of them have stories attached.
I haven't thought out the logistics of it yet, like how to burn the CDs or get supplies, etc but this is something we can add songs to over the next year and continually work on until the wedding. Anyone else ever seen this before?